Review: Adele Ashworth, Winter Garden

Adele Ashworth’s Winter Garden (Jove, 2000) is a favorite among romance readers, and ends up in the top third of the AAR Readers poll every year. It is out of print and I couldn’t find it in non-pirated digital (although in a TGTBTU interview in January of this year, Ashworth said not only is Winter Garden available in e, but that it is being reissued in the near future. Color me confuzzled.) I was attracted to the title, and the cover (A lone fully dressed man standing near a garden. How did that get by the Mandatory Mantitty Committee?) and obtained a rather expensive pre-read volume through Amazon. It was well worth it: Winter Garden is one of the most unusual, romantic, and thought-provoking romances I have ever had the pleasure of reading.

The book, set in Victorian England (1849) begins with Madeleine DuMais, a French spy for the British government, arriving at a cottage in Winter Garden to begin her new assignment. Madeleine’s father was a British naval officer, but she spent her childhood with her French mother, an actress who was selfish, neglectful, and addicted to opium. The resilience, cunning and determination that helped Madeleine survive her abusive childhood — not to mention her renowned beauty and charm — have served her well in her role as spy. When she is called by the British government to sleepy retreat of Winter Garden to help foil an opium smuggling operation, Madeleine knows only that she will pose as a French tutor to a fellow spy, Thomas Blackwood, who is himself posing as a reclusive scholar.

The cottage is quiet when she arrives, so Madeleine goes looking for her partner. She ends up in the back yard:

Then she saw the man. Madeleine came to an abrupt halt and stared open-mouthed. It was a ridiculous reaction on her part, she realized at once. Yet she’d never before, in her very experienced life, seen anyone like him. The graphic sexual thoughts suddenly rolling through her mind actually startled her.

He stood along the far end of the property, probably only ten feet away. His back was to her, legs spread wide in a chopping stance, naked from the hips up as he effortlessly lifted an ax and slammed it into the brush in an attempt to clear the overgrowth. He was huge of stature and beautifully muscled from his bunched shoulders and sculpted arms, through the cords of strength along his back, to his lean, tapered waist that disappeared into tight black pants hugging long, thick, booted legs.

Right away, two unusual characteristics of this heroine — Madeleine’s sexual experience, and her instant and strong attraction to Thomas — are conveyed to the reader. On the other hand, the description of the hero, while vivid, is pretty standard fare.

But then…

With another quick glance into her eyes, he took his first few steps toward her, and that’s when Madeleine understood his reluctance all too clearly. His limp was pronounced, shocking her in a measure he probably noticed. Or expected.

At first impression, she concluded it wasn’t a recent, healing injury. Thomas favored his right leg, although both appeared to be afflicted. From the way he moved, she knew it had to be an old wound that had likely left scars.

“Thomas—” He paused in midstride, effectively cutting her off, but he didn’t meet her gaze.

“It’s all right, Madeleine,” he replied in a deep whisper. Then he brushed by her so closely she felt the heat from his body, and she instinctively took a step away.

This first meeting sets up the dynamic in their relationship that carries us through quite a bit of the book: Madeleine wanting Thomas, and Thomas resisting her. Madeleine doesn’t understand why two adults can’t have a little mutually consenting fun, but the reader can sense right away that there is a lot more going on with Thomas than meets the eye. He has an agenda, and it involves Madeleine, but what it is doesn’t become clear until near the end of the book.

Thomas is clearly haunted by whatever caused his severe injuries, and is extremely vulnerable. He seems to want something of Madeleine, something deep and important. Madeleine is pretty much unaware of the turmoil she causes in Thomas, and approaches him in the same forthright, witty and intelligent manner she approaches everything.

Their work on identifying and foiling the opium ring is really just a pretext for the character development, although Ashworth populates Winter Garden with a number of interesting and vivid — but not stereotyped — secondary characters. It was refreshing to read a romance set in a functioning small town, other than London, with its own rules and intertwined personal histories.

But the real draw of this book for me was the relationship, which I relished both because it was unusual, and because it was so passionate and romantic. Here’s Thomas and Madeleine walking outside at night. Of course, they are supposed to be doing reconnaissance, but the real action is in their conversation with each other.

Madeleine is thinking aloud about a passionate kiss they recently shared:

“So, after days of reflection,” she concluded, “I decided that this was strictly because you were so centered in it. Our kiss totally consumed you—not in style or the desire to please, but in its sheer intensity. You put everything into it while restraining yourself from going farther physically, even after I practically begged you to.”

Madeleine dropped her voice to a husky whisper. “I don’t think I’ve ever before witnessed such a singular response in a man.”

He hesitated briefly in his stride, drawing a long, slow breath, and she took advantage of his momentary unsureness.

“And do you know what else I think, Thomas?”

“No, but I’m beginning to fear it.”

She grinned broadly and squeezed his hand. “I think it was the most wondrous of any kiss I’ve experienced in years.”

That comment, uttered in absolute honesty, drew him to a standstill. He turned to face her, gazing down into her eyes, his voice and features heavy with caution.

“If that’s a compliment, then I’m very flattered. But I have my doubts that a woman as sophisticated and lovely as you would consider an awkward kiss from me to be wondrous.”

“You find me lovely, Thomas?” she pressed softly, instantly filled with satisfaction, knowing he’d said this before, but sighting deeper meaning in it now.

Without pause, he whispered, “I find you breathtaking beyond adequate words, Madeleine.”

There are two major surprises in store for readers of this book, which I cannot talk about without spoiling it completely. They caused me to go back immediately to page one and start over. Now, when I reread even their very first meeting, I see it very differently. It’s kind of like watching The Usual Suspects again after you find out who Keyser Sose is.

My one question or quibble with the book involves the second of those surprises, so here is a spoiler warning:

BEGIN SPOILER

*

*

*

*

Readers get Thomas’s full backstory — who he was prior to his injury, and what his real relationship to Maddie is — near the end of the book. We find out that he had in fact met her years ago, while he was newly injured, and fell in love with her instantly for her beauty and the respectful and caring way she interacted with him. I can believe that a chance encounter can be completely forgotten by one person, while it reorients and anchors another person’s broken life. It’s incredibly romantic, actually. A kind of “I came across time for you, Sarah” moment.

But Thomas’s revelations forced me to reevaluate both characters in a way that wasn’t totally comfortable for me. As a reader, I have been admiring Madeleine all along for her grit and success in a man’s world. Now I find out that their “mission” is a sham, and that she owes her very career to Thomas.

Also, I have been charmed from the beginning by Thomas’s combination of vulnerability and pride, but now I find out he has been manipulating things all along. He has been in total control, not only of Madeleine, but of the whole spy outfit. They are not equals, he is her superior.

And yet, Madeleine is truly strong (Thomas has a point that without his intervention, she may not have ever been given a chance), and Thomas is deeply vulnerable to Madeleine. So in the end, I decided these revelations served to complicate the characters in believable and interesting ways, and ultimately to deepen my appreciation of this book.

*

*

*

*

END SPOILER

I had read and enjoyed one other title by Ashworth, Duke of Scandal Sin, and plan to read more. Unfortunately, Ashworth’s website is her Harper Collins author page, which doesn’t even list Winter Garden, so it’s not easy to get a full back list.

I can’t actually tell if Winter Garden is part of a series. Some sites say A Notorious Proposition (2008) is the “second book in the Winter Garden series”, and other sites say that Winter Garden is the sequel to Stolen Charms (1999).

The first of Ashworth’s dukes trilogy, The Duke’s Captive, was recently published.

Here are some other reviews:

Rosario, A+

All About Romance, A
and their Pandora’s Box on the book.

The Romance Reader, 5 hearts

The Bookkeeper, positive

7 responses

  1. Thanks for linking to my review. ITA with your review. This is the first book that I have come across a reason for one partner leaving the other that is totally understandable. For a moment it did throw a very unfavourable, stalker-like light on Thomas, but I cut him some slack in the end. He was just too nice otherwise.
    Even though it looks like a series, I don’t think the other books are even remotely related to this one.
    I have read Duke of Sin since (review on my blog as well) and liked it, too. It also featured quite unusual protagonists for a romance novel.

    Like

  2. I was lucky enough to read this book when it first came out and was captivated by it. It’s not usual to find a sexually experienced heroine and that alone made it worth reading. Though it’s been quite some time now that I read it, I do remember my heart aching for Thomas – even after finishing the book.
    I’m glad to see it’s coming out again so others can read it.

    Like

  3. Near perfect romance about two mature sexual people who love deeply. Very erotic and emotional but also quiet in the sense that I can still see Thomas and Madeline growing old together, sitting on their bench, holding hands and reflecting on their lives together while their grandchildren play around them.

    I still have my first edition copy *hugs close*

    Like

  4. Aargh. I wish I could take part in this discussion, but it’s been so long since I read WG and her other books around that time. About ten years ago? That long ago? *sob* AA’s plotting (and occasionally, characterisation) tends to be, hmm, illogical sometimes (A Notorious Proposition and Someone Irresistible – I actually quite like this one, but a lot of readers disliked it (probably because heroine went after ‘beta’ hero) – for examples). She reminds me of an archer friend who – his talent is obvious to all – often missed the bull’s eye because of his attempts to be different from the others with his handling of the bow. I loved that cover of Winter Garden. I loved the cover of Stolen Charms a lot more. Wish there’re more covers like those two.

    The only connection between Stolen Charms and Winter Garden is Madeleine. I’m not sure if I could classify WG as a sequel to SC. It might be better to classify it as part of an universe. Like so:

    Stolen Charms (Madeleine appears as a minor (secondary-ish?) character)
    Winter Garden (Madeleine’s own story)
    A Notorious Proposition (takes place in Winter Garden town; I don’t remember if Madeleine and Thomas make appearances)
    The Duke’s Captive (Ian – brother of Ivy from ANP – has his own story here; also takes place in Winter Garden town)

    All can be read as standalones. Here’s Adele Ashworth’s bibliography (as far as I know, anyroad) in order:

    Winter Garden universe:
    Stolen Charms
    Winter Garden
    A Notorious Proposition
    The Duke’s Captive

    Duke universe:
    Duke of Sin
    Duke of Scandal
    The Duke’s Indiscretion

    Non-series
    My Darling Caroline [debut]
    Someone Irresistible
    When It’s Perfect

    Like

  5. Excellent review, this is one of my favourite romances, exactly for the reasons you mention. I don’t think Ashworth’s written anything nearly as good since then, although I do remember liking My Darling Caroline (her debut) very much.

    On that spoiler…

    SPOILER
    .
    .
    .

    As a reader, I have been admiring Madeleine all along for her grit and success in a man’s world. Now I find out that their “mission” is a sham, and that she owes her very career to Thomas.

    That did give me pause initially, but…. It’s been a little while since I last reread this, but IIRC, while Thomas had been the one to decide to give her a chance, and had somewhat manipulated the direction her career took, it hadn’t been a fake spying career at all. She had done the work, and she had been brilliant at it. She had more than earned her success, whatever the circumstances of her being recruited.

    Maili: Stolen Charms (Madeleine appears as a minor (secondary-ish?) character)

    She quite stole the show in that book. Again, it’s been a while, but I think she actually propositions the hero of SC, and she was so much more interesting than the slightly insipid heroine. At the time, it was extremely daring to then make her the heroine of her own novel!

    Like

  6. @Rikki: Hi Rikki. no problem. I agree with the necessity of the separation. I wouldn’t have liked the book at all if Madeleine hadn’t had such a negative reaction to the revelations.

    @Victoria Janssen: Another argument for digitizing backlists!

    @KristieJ: I agree. It was so unusual, and how refreshing to have a sexually forthright heroine. I look forward to the reissue, because my paper copy is already worse for wear.

    @katiebabs: Great summary, Kate. and yes, hold on to that first edition!

    @Maili: oh, thanks much for that list. Who is the couple in ANP I wonder? Someone we’ve met in WG?

    ps. You have an archer friend? Huh.

    @Rosario: Agreed completely that she had a real career — I probably overstated it in my review.

    And thanks for that insight into SC! there are so many secondary characters who deserve their own books, and so many who don;t get them because of perceptions about what readers will accept. I am glad Ashworth took the chance on Madeleine.

    Like

Prof's Progress

... on making sense, one word at a time

Bkwurm.com

Bkwurm: /book*worm/ n. a person devoted to reading and study

VacuousMinx

Blog in Progress

Nyssa Harkness

Media and Cultural Studies with a focus on Genre Fiction, Gaming and Creative Society

Shelf Love

live mines and duds: the reading life

Love is the Best Medicine

Harlequin/Mills and Boon Medical Romance Authors

Blue Moon

Audiobook reviews and book reviews. Occasional opining.

specficromantic

reviews by a speculative fiction romantic

Centre for Medical Humanities

News, updates and insights from the Centre for Medical Humanities, Durham University

Miss Bates Reads Romance

Miss Bates is the loquacious spinster from Austen's Emma. No doubt she read romances ... here's what she would have thought of them.

Badass Romance

heroes, heroines, and books that demand to be taken seriously

bad necklace: not quite pearls of wisdom

mala, media, maladies, and malapropisms

Thinking in Fragments

but making connections too

Tales from the Reading Room

A Literary Salon Where All Are Welcome

momisatwork

thinking about teaching, learning, home and family

Feminist Philosophers

News feminist philosophers can use

Fit and Feminist

Because it takes strong women to smash the patriarchy.

Fit Is a Feminist Issue

(previously known as "Fit, Feminist, and (almost) Fifty," but we're not going to be "almost fifty" forever!

Heloise Merlin's Weblog

Virtual people read books, too!

Victoria Janssen

Just another WordPress.com site

Bblog Central

Your source for book blogging.

Insta-Love Book Reviews

Deflowering romance - one book at a time

A Striped Armchair

Bookish thoughts from a woman of endless curiousity

Sonomalass's Blog

Another day in paradise

RR@H Novel Thoughts & Book Talk

Featuring Author Interviews and Commentaries

Something More

my extensive reading

The Romantic Goldfish

"Cheapest mother fucking goldfish on the planet"

Shallowreader's Blog

...barely scratching the surface of romance literature, reading and libraries

Joanna Chambers, author

Historical romance

THE DAILY RUCKUS

ROYALTY, ROMANCE NOVELS, AND A LITTLE RUCKUS

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,421 other followers

%d bloggers like this: